THEORETICAL, METHODOLOGICAL AND SECTORAL ASPECTS OF UNDERSTANDING GUILT AS A LEGAL CATEGORY

Olga Avdeeva; Vadim A. Avdeev

UDC 334.01

THEORETICAL, METHODOLOGICAL AND SECTORAL ASPECTS OF UNDERSTANDING GUILT AS A LEGAL CATEGORY

Published in Vestnik of the East Siberian institute of the Ministry of internal affairs of the Russian Federation · Issue 1 · Pages 11–27 · Rubric: Theoretical and historical legal sciences

Received: 19.01.2024 Accepted: 26.01.2024 Published: 10.04.2024

Authors

Olga Avdeeva

ORCID

Vadim A. Avdeev

ORCID

Olga Avdeeva

Academic degree: doctor of jurisprudence sciences

Science rang: docent

East Siberian Institute of the MIA of Russia Russian Federation

ORCID

Vadim A. Avdeev

Academic degree: doctor of jurisprudence sciences

Science rang: professor

Yugra State University Professor · criminal law and criminal process · Russian Federation · Khanty-Mansiysk

ORCID

ABSTRACT

Introduction: the article analyses the scientific understanding of guilt as a legal category; investigates the peculiarities of the formation of the concept of guilt in philosophical and legal thought at different stages of state-legal development; reveals the specificity of scientific approaches to the understanding of guilt in the formation and development of psychology; identifies the stages of modification of theoretical and legal approaches to the concept and construction of guilt; reflects the diversity of approaches to the concept and construction of guilt in the legal science of criminal profile; considers the legislative model of regulation of guilt in the legal science of criminal profile. Materials and Methods: the study of guilt as a legal category, based on the disclosure of the features of the theoretical, methodological and sectoral understanding of its essence and construction, led to the use of both general scientific logical and philosophical, including dialectical, and private scientific methods of cognition, among which the key role was assigned to formal legal, comparative legal and psychological methods. The Results of the Study: the study of guilt as a legal category, based on the disclosure of the peculiarities of theoretical-methodological and sectoral understanding of its essence and construction, conditioned the use of both general scientific logical and philosophical, including dialectical, and private-scientific methods of cognition, among which the key role was given to formal-legal, comparative-legal and psychological methods. Findings and Conclusions: he position that theoretical-methodological and sectoral doctrinal and legislative approaches to understanding and regulation of guilt are based on the combination of psychological, evaluative and normative criteria, taking into account the doctrinal formula developed in the framework of the theory of dangerous state of personality, volitional theory, theory of representation, etc. is substantiated. The psychological criterion for assessing guilt consists in the fact that a person, entering into legal relations, realises certain interests caused by a specific need. Realisation of this interest entails the search for the object of its satisfaction, which gives rise to the purpose and motive of the carried out activity. As a result, a person, guided by the arisen interest, purpose and motive taking into account the necessity, strives to achieve them to satisfy his needs. In the presence of alternative variants of predicted (lawful or delinquent) behaviour occurs, taking into account the "struggle of motives", the subject chooses and makes a volitional decision on the implementation of a particular action, chooses the means of achieving the goal and then implements the intended act. An offence is characterised by the correlation of intellectual, emotional and volitional components in a person's behaviour. Guilt as a legal category has an asocial essence, which is manifested in the presence of asocial attitudes of a person, allowing him to express in the form of action or inaction neglectful, negative or insufficiently careful attitude to the objects of legal protection. The criteria of legal understanding of guilt should be considered qualitative and quantitative characteristics, including its essence, content, degree, form and volume.

KEYWORDS

legal regulation, legal relationship, offense, the subjective side of the offense, guilt, guilt, legal responsibility.

1. Rarog A. I. Vina v sovetskom ugolovnom prave [Guilt in Soviet criminal law]. Saratov, 1987, 186 p.

2. Feldstein G. S. Priroda umysla [The nature of intent]. Sbornik pravovedenija i obshhestvennyh znanij – Collection of jurisprudence and public knowledge. M., 1898, 22 p.

3. Kant I. Sochinenija: v 6 tomah. [Works: in 6 volumes]. M., 1965, vol. 4, part II, 478 p.

4. Hegel G. V. F. Filosofija prava [Philosophy of Law]. M.: USSR Academy of Sciences, Institute of Philosophy, Publishing House "Thought", 1990, 524 p .

5. Leibniz G. Novye opyty o chelovecheskom razume [New experiments on the human mind]. M.L., Social Analysis, 1936, 484 p.

6. Spinoza B. Izbrannye proizvedenija [Selected works]. M.: Gospolitizdat, 1957, In 2 volumes. vol. 1, 631 p.

7. Shershenevich G.F. Obshhaja teorija prava [General theory of law]. M.: Edition of the Bashmakov Brothers, 1910, 814 p.

8. Tagantsev N. S. Russkoe ugolovnoe pravo [Russian criminal law]. Tula: Autograph, 2001, part 1, 800 p.

9. Poznyshev S.V. Osnovnye nachala nauki ugolovnogo prava. Obshhaja Chast' ugolovnogo prava. [The basic principles of the science of criminal law. The general part of criminal law. The second edition is expanded]. M.: Edition by A.A. Kartsev, 1912, 653 p.

10. Nemirovsky E. Ya. Mery social'noj zashhity i nakazanie v svjazi s sushhnost'ju viny [Measures of social protection and punishment in connection with the essence of guilt]. Zadachi po ugolovnomu pravu: s prilozheniem stat'i "Mery social'noj zashhity i nakazanie v svjazi s sushhnost'ju viny" – Tasks in criminal law: with the appendix of the article “Measures of social protection and punishment in connection with the essence of guilt.” No. 51. Ed. 2nd. 2016. 136 p. (Series: Academy of Basic Research: History of Law).

11. Utevsky B. S. Vina v sovetskom ugolovnom prave [Guilt in Soviet criminal law]. M., 1950, 318 p.

12. Dagel P. S. Soderzhanie, forma i sushhnost' viny v sovetskom ugolovnom prave [The content, form and essence of guilt in Soviet criminal law]. Izvestija vysshih uchebnyh zavedenij. Pravovedenie – News of higher educational institutions. Jurisprudence. 1969, no. 1, pp. 78-88.

13. Krieger G. A., Kuznetsova N. F., Tkachevsky Yu. M. (ed.) Sovetskoe ugolovnoe pravo – Soviet criminal law. M., 1988, 367 p.

14. Valuiskov N. V., Bondarenko L. V., Harutyunyan A.D. Ponjatie viny i vinovnosti v ugolovnom prave [The concept of guilt and guilt in criminal law]. Baltijskij gumanitarnyj zhurnal – Baltic Humanitarian Journal. 2017, vol. 6, no. 3 (20), pp. 345–347.

15. Tarkhanov I. A. Problemy viny, vinovnosti i dejatel'nogo raskajanija v osnovnyh ugolovno-pravovyh sistemah sovremennosti (doktrinal'nyj i zakonotvorcheskij aspekty) [Problems of guilt, guilt and active repentance in the main criminal legal systems of modernity (doctrinal and law-making aspects)]. Uchenye zapiski Kazanskogo universiteta. Serija gumanitarnye nauki – Scientific notes of the Kazan University. The Humanities series. 2019, vol. 161, book 1, pp. 121-140.

16. Kvashis V. E. Prestupnaja neostorozhnost'. Social'no-pravovye i kriminologicheskie problem [Criminal negligence. Socio-legal and criminological problems]. Vladivostok, 1986, 189 p.

JATS XML

Chief Editor

Olga Avdeeva

Executive Secretary

Anatoliy Tirskih

fvs-mvd@mail.ru

1377

downloads

GOST

Avdeeva O. A., Avdeev V. A. THEORETICAL, METHODOLOGICAL AND SECTORAL ASPECTS OF UNDERSTANDING GUILT AS A LEGAL CATEGORY // Vestnik of the East Siberian institute of the Ministry of internal affairs of the Russian Federation. 2024. no. 1. pp. 11-27. URL: https://kvsz.ru/en/nauka/publications/article/6a9c154332807fdbab867e40/theoretical-methodological-and-sectoral-aspects-of-understanding-guilt-as-a-legal-category/view. (Date of access 28.10.2026).

MLA

Olga Avdeeva, Avdeev V. A.. "THEORETICAL, METHODOLOGICAL AND SECTORAL ASPECTS OF UNDERSTANDING GUILT AS A LEGAL CATEGORY." Vestnik of the East Siberian institute of the Ministry of internal affairs of the Russian Federation.1 (2024): 11-27. URL: https://kvsz.ru/en/nauka/publications/article/6a9c154332807fdbab867e40/theoretical-methodological-and-sectoral-aspects-of-understanding-guilt-as-a-legal-category/view.

APA

Avdeeva O. A., Avdeev V. A. (2024). THEORETICAL, METHODOLOGICAL AND SECTORAL ASPECTS OF UNDERSTANDING GUILT AS A LEGAL CATEGORY. Vestnik of the East Siberian institute of the Ministry of internal affairs of the Russian Federation(1), 11-27. URL: https://kvsz.ru/en/nauka/publications/article/6a9c154332807fdbab867e40/theoretical-methodological-and-sectoral-aspects-of-understanding-guilt-as-a-legal-category/view

Chicago

Olga Avdeeva, Avdeev V. A.. "THEORETICAL, METHODOLOGICAL AND SECTORAL ASPECTS OF UNDERSTANDING GUILT AS A LEGAL CATEGORY." Vestnik of the East Siberian institute of the Ministry of internal affairs of the Russian Federation, no. 1 (2024): 11-27. URL: https://kvsz.ru/en/nauka/publications/article/6a9c154332807fdbab867e40/theoretical-methodological-and-sectoral-aspects-of-understanding-guilt-as-a-legal-category/view.

WIKI

{{cite journal | author = Avdeeva O. A., Avdeev V. A. | title = THEORETICAL, METHODOLOGICAL AND SECTORAL ASPECTS OF UNDERSTANDING GUILT AS A LEGAL CATEGORY | journal = Vestnik of the East Siberian institute of the Ministry of internal affairs of the Russian Federation | year = 2024 | issue = 1 | pages = 11-27 | url = https://kvsz.ru/en/nauka/publications/article/6a9c154332807fdbab867e40/theoretical-methodological-and-sectoral-aspects-of-understanding-guilt-as-a-legal-category/view }}

Copy

Export: BibTeX EndNote RefMan RusMARC

THEORETICAL, METHODOLOGICAL AND SECTORAL ASPECTS OF UNDERSTANDING GUILT AS A LEGAL CATEGORY

Confirmation