OTHER MEASURES OF A CRIMINAL LEGAL NATURE:  EFFICIENCY ANALYSIS

Ekaterina Barkhatova; A L Repetskaya

VAK Russia 5 UDC 34 CSCSTI 10.00 Russian Classification of Professions by Education 40.00.00 Russian Library and Bibliographic Classification 6 Russian Trade and Bibliographic Classification 7 BISAC LAW

7 more Collapse

OTHER MEASURES OF A CRIMINAL LEGAL NATURE: EFFICIENCY ANALYSIS

Published in Vestnik of the East Siberian institute of the Ministry of internal affairs of the Russian Federation · Issue 3 · Pages 181–193 · Rubric: Criminal law sciences

Received: 10.04.2024 Accepted: 20.05.2024 Published: 02.10.2024

Authors

Ekaterina Barkhatova

ORCID SPIN

A L Repetskaya

Ekaterina Barkhatova

Academic degree: candidate of jurisprudence sciences

Science rang: docent

The East-Siberian Institute of the MIA of Russia Associate Professor of the Department · Department of Criminal Law and Criminology · Russian Federation · Irkutsk

the East Siberian Institute of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia Associate Professor · the Department of Criminal Law and Criminology · Russian Federation · Irkutsk

ORCID SPIN

A L Repetskaya

Vostochno-Sibirskiy institut MVD Rossii

ABSTRACT

Introduction: Other measures of a criminal legal nature are one of the levers of the criminal legal mechanism, allowing for a harmonious combination of punitive and incentive effects. At the same time, recently the question of their effectiveness has been increasingly raised, due in one case to a reduction in the number of facts of their use, in another - to the nuances of legislative regulation. Materials and Methods: The research used the work of domestic scientists, criminal statistics, and regulatory documents. When writing the article, general scientific methods were used: a systematic approach, induction, analogy, analysis, synthesis, as well as the private scientific method of extrapolation, which made it possible to obtain the main results of the study. The Results of the Study: An analysis of statistical data reflecting the results of the application of criminal law norms on other measures of a criminal legal nature was carried out, both in terms of changes in indicators in dynamics and structure, and in terms of the repeated commission of crimes and socially dangerous acts by persons to whom such measures were applied . Findings and Conclusions: Conclusions are drawn about a fairly high level of their effectiveness and prospects for further development. It is indicated that the procedure for applying other measures of a criminal law nature requires refinement, and the status of some of them also requires clarification, which affects the quality of their application.

KEYWORDS

criminal law, compulsory medical measures, confiscation of property, court fine, effectiveness analysis, socially dangerous acts of the insane

Funding

1. Korneev, S.A. Prinuditel'nye mery medicinskogo haraktera v strukture ugolovno-pravovogo vozdejstvija [Compulsory medical measures in the structure of criminal law]. Vestnik Saratovskoj gosudarstvennoj juridicheskoj akademii. - Bulletin of the Saratov State Law Academy. 2021. 2. Pp. 153-160.

2. Fedorova, E.A. Prinuditel'nye mery medicinskogo haraktera v ugolovnom zakonodatel'stve Rossijskoj Federacii: uchebnoe posobie. [Compulsory medical measures in the criminal legislation of the Russian Federation: tutorial]. Krasnoyarsk, 2021. 80 p. (in Russian).

3. Markelova, A.S. Statisticheskoe issledovanie social'no-demograficheskoj differenciacii sudimosti naselenija Rossii: diss. … kand. jekonom. nauk. [Statistical study of socio-demographic differentiation of the criminal record of the Russian population: dissertation. ...cand. economy sciences]. M., 2004. 173 p. (in Russian).

4. Shageeva, R.M. Problemy primenenija prinuditel'nyh mer medicinskogo haraktera v ugolovnom processe: avtoref. diss. … kand. jurid. nauk. [Problems of using compulsory medical measures in criminal proceedings: abstract. diss. ...cand. legal Sci.] Ufa, 2005. 28 p. (in Russian).

5. Vidergol'd, A.I. Realizacija sudebnyh pravovyh pozicij Verhovnogo suda Rossijskoj Federacii, kasajushhihsja voprosov o primenenii sudami prinuditel'nyh mer medicinskogo haraktera. [Implementation of judicial legal positions of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation concerning issues of the use of compulsory measures of a medical nature by courts]. Vestnik Juzhno-Ural'skogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Serija: Pravo. - Bulletin of the South Ural State University. Series: Law. 2015. № 3. Pp. 36-41. (in Russian).

6. Skoblikov, P.A. Sovremennye problemy preduprezhdenija i presechenija obshhestvenno opasnyh dejanij so storony lic s psihicheskimi rasstrojstvami, uzhe sovershavshih analogichnye dejanija. [Modern problems of preventing and suppressing socially dangerous acts by persons with mental disorders who have already committed similar acts]. Sibirskij juridicheskij vestnik. - Siberian Legal Bulletin. 2023. № 3. Pp. 79-86. (in Russian).

7. Makushkina, O.A., Jakimovich, L.A. Povtornye obshhestvenno opasnye dejstvija lic, stradajushhih psihicheskimi rasstrojstvami: problemy profilaktiki. [Repeated socially dangerous actions of persons suffering from mental disorders: problems of prevention]/ Rossijskij psihiatricheskij zhurnal. - Russian Psychiatric Journal. 2014. № 2. Pp. 4-10. (in Russian).

8. Sudebno-psihiatricheskaja profilaktika v Rossijskoj Federacii: analiticheskij obzor / pod red. B.A. Kazakovceva, O.A. Makushkinoj. [Forensic psychiatric prevention in the Russian Federation: analytical review / ed. B.A. Kazakovtseva, O.A. Makushkina]. M.: FGBU GNCSSP im. V.P. Serbskogo Minzdravsocrazvitija Rossii, 2012. 356 p. (in Russian).

9. Golland, V.B., Laz'ko, N.V., Rumjancev, V.A. Dinamika pokazatelej, harakterizujushhih sostojanie okazanija prinuditel'nogo lechenija v Rossijskoj Federacii po dannym godovyh otchetov «Svedenija o kontingentah bol'nyh s psihicheskimi rasstrojstvami, nahodjashhihsja na aktivnom dispansernom nabljudenii i prinuditel'nom lechenii» (Forma № 36-PL) v 2006-2016 gg.». [Dynamics of indicators characterizing the state of provision of compulsory treatment in the Russian Federation according to the annual reports «Information on the contingents of patients with mental disorders undergoing active dispensary observation and compulsory treatment” (Form No. 36-PL) in 2006-2016»]. URL: https://docs.yandex.ru/docs/view?tm=1712558889&tld=ru&lang=ru&name (data obrashhenija: 08.04.2024). (in Russian).

10. Maslov, V.A. Jeffektivnost' konfiskacii imushhestva v kontekste oficial'noj statistiki. [The effectiveness of property confiscation in the context of official statistics]. Aktual'nye problemy rossijskogo prava. - Current problems of Russian law. 2022. T. 17. № 12. Pp. 175-190. (in Russian).

JATS XML

Chief Editor

Olga Avdeeva

Executive Secretary

Anatoliy Tirskih

fvs-mvd@mail.ru

10109

downloads

GOST

Barkhatova E. N., Repetskaya A. L. OTHER MEASURES OF A CRIMINAL LEGAL NATURE: EFFICIENCY ANALYSIS // Vestnik of the East Siberian institute of the Ministry of internal affairs of the Russian Federation. 2024. no. 3. pp. 181-193. URL: https://kvsz.ru/en/nauka/publications/article/6a9c155e32807fdbab869d34/other-measures-of-a-criminal-legal-nature-efficiency-analysis/view. (Date of access 22.09.2026).

MLA

Ekaterina Barkhatova, Repetskaya A. L.. "OTHER MEASURES OF A CRIMINAL LEGAL NATURE: EFFICIENCY ANALYSIS." Vestnik of the East Siberian institute of the Ministry of internal affairs of the Russian Federation.3 (2024): 181-193. URL: https://kvsz.ru/en/nauka/publications/article/6a9c155e32807fdbab869d34/other-measures-of-a-criminal-legal-nature-efficiency-analysis/view.

APA

Barkhatova E. N., Repetskaya A. L. (2024). OTHER MEASURES OF A CRIMINAL LEGAL NATURE: EFFICIENCY ANALYSIS. Vestnik of the East Siberian institute of the Ministry of internal affairs of the Russian Federation(3), 181-193. URL: https://kvsz.ru/en/nauka/publications/article/6a9c155e32807fdbab869d34/other-measures-of-a-criminal-legal-nature-efficiency-analysis/view

Chicago

Ekaterina Barkhatova, Repetskaya A. L.. "OTHER MEASURES OF A CRIMINAL LEGAL NATURE: EFFICIENCY ANALYSIS." Vestnik of the East Siberian institute of the Ministry of internal affairs of the Russian Federation, no. 3 (2024): 181-193. URL: https://kvsz.ru/en/nauka/publications/article/6a9c155e32807fdbab869d34/other-measures-of-a-criminal-legal-nature-efficiency-analysis/view.

WIKI

{{cite journal | author = Barkhatova E. N., Repetskaya A. L. | title = OTHER MEASURES OF A CRIMINAL LEGAL NATURE: EFFICIENCY ANALYSIS | journal = Vestnik of the East Siberian institute of the Ministry of internal affairs of the Russian Federation | year = 2024 | issue = 3 | pages = 181-193 | url = https://kvsz.ru/en/nauka/publications/article/6a9c155e32807fdbab869d34/other-measures-of-a-criminal-legal-nature-efficiency-analysis/view }}

Copy

Export: BibTeX EndNote RefMan RusMARC

OTHER MEASURES OF A CRIMINAL LEGAL NATURE: EFFICIENCY ANALYSIS

Confirmation